Fire in the Hole Burger

All natural since day 1 burger, crispy jalapenos, pepper jack cheese, Aardvark habanero pickle relish on our branded bun.  Take cover!

Surf & Turf Burger

All natural since day 1 burger, topped with shrimp, pepper jack cheese and our sweet and spicy aioli.  Made with shrimp caught right here in the bay (NOT!).

Black Bean Burger

Cows are too cute to eat?  Try this!  Black beans, roasted corn and smoky chipotle peppers, with lettuce, tomato, onion and served with your choice of cheese on our branded bun.

Build your own!

Just tell your server what you want and we'll do it!

Street Tacos

Served a la carte on a hand pressed flour shell.  Order as many as you want... mix and match to your heart's desire!  Priced per taco.

Shrimp Tacos

Shrimp, served with an avocado pico de gallo and a cilantro lime aioli.

Tuna Tacos

Seared Ahi Tuna, with avocado, sprouts and our wasabi cream sauce.

Pulled Beef Tacos

Our house braised beef mixed with a ropa vieja sauce, with cheese and served with a corn & black bean relish.

Perch Tacos

It’s like we wrapped the Great Lakes in a tortilla!  Fried perch, stuffed with citrus slaw and our house made chipotle ranch sauce.

Blackened Fish Sandwich

Blackened cod on our multi-grain bun and topped with lettuce, tomato and house-made mango tartar.

Battered Cod Sandwich

Beer battered cod, with lettuce, tomato and house made mango tartar sauce on our branded bun.

Lobster Roll

Let’s get your island party REELY rolling!  Delicious lobster meat and fish mixed with mayo, lemon juice, green onion and celery, served on a New England style roll.

BBQ Chicken Wrap

Wrrrrrap it up! Grilled all natural chicken breast, lettuce, cheddar cheese and tortilla strips covered in BBQ sauce, then wrapped in a red pepper wrap (don't fret, it's not spicy).

Veggie Sloppy Joe

Black beans and assorted veggies in our house made sloppy joe sauce, topped with sprouts and served on a multi-grain bun.  It’s delish!

Chicken Tenders

Do you really need a description? OK…Strips of chicken fried golden brown, served with our house cut fries, along with your choice of dipping sauce (Ranch, BBQ, Hot BBQ or Honey Mustard).

Potato Crusted Grouper

Florida grouper lightly crusted with potato, served over fried plantains with coconut rice, grilled zucchini, summer squash and mango tartar sauce.

Sirloin Steak

 Sirloin steak cooked to order served with Brussel sprouts and bacon lardons along with a baked potato.

Hale Kale Caesar

In 70 B.C., when Julius Caesar visited Reel Bar, he loved this salad (this is complete B.S.)  Baby kale and romaine mix with Caesar dressing and topped with parmesan cheese and garlic croutons.

Southwestern

Greens topped with black beans, edamame, grilled corn, red onion, cheddar cheese, tortilla strips and drizzled with BBQ and ranch dressing.

Tomato Bisque

w/ tomato and onion chunks, cream & a hint of sherry.

REEL Tots

If your Mom Reely loved you, why didn't she make 'em this way? Huge homemade tater tots, covered in cheddar cheese, sprinkled with scallions, served w/jalapeño sour cream.

Spiced Edamame

Just to prove you can have a healthy and tasty snack at Put-in-Bay, here’s edamame served in the pod and lightly coated with smoky chipotle salt.

Pickle Chips

You know you want ‘em! Our famous breaded pickle slices, deep fried and served with a chipotle ranch dipping sauce.

Short Rib Eggroll

Short rib wrapped up with peppers and onion in an egg roll wrapper, then deep fried. Served with horseradish aioli & au jus.

Ohio Drums

“Natural Since Day 1” Ohio chicken drums covered in sweet and spicy go-chu-jang sauce (whatever that is, it’s good!).

Chicken Wings

Seven meaty wings, ripped off a chicken and smothered in your choice of sauce (Hot, buffalo, garlic Parmesan, sweet chili, spicy garlic Parmesan, BBQ, hot BBQ or buffalo ranch Parmesan).  Our regulars love these!

Tuna Nachos

Seared tuna, avocado, scallions and lettuce, served over tortilla chips, drizzled with wasabi cream sauce & Sriracha

Loaded Fresh Cut Fries

Our fresh cut fries covered with queso. Reely load ‘em up by adding: Sausage, Fried egg, Cole Slaw and/or Bacon

Reel Slaw

A fresh mix of shredded cabbage, shaved broccoli, Brussel sprouts and kale fused with our special Cole Slaw dressing.

Fresh Cut Fries

We take potatoes, and cut these fries fresh in our kitchen!

Onion Rings

Battered Onion rings with our chipotle ranch dipping sauce.

Side Salad

Mixed greens, cheddar cheese, tomato, onion and your choice of dressing.

Reel Bar’s famous “Filthy Oar Shot”

16 craft and domestic beers on tap

Domestic and imported bottled beer

Fresh Squeezed Cocktails

(Fresh Squeezed OJ or grapefruit with your choice of liquor)

Large collection of fine bourbons

Wine

Soft Drinks

Fresh Brewed Iced Tea

Specialty Shots and Cocktails

Fresh Squeezed Mimosas